Championships and individual honors across John Mayberry’s DBL career.
Title seasons and postseason series won with the player’s team.
1984
Baltimore Orioles 
1981
St. Louis Cardinals Awards grouped by type, with every recorded season and team shown below.
Recognition for excellence at the player’s position.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| Gold Glove 2× |
1979
St. Louis Cardinals
1978
Pittsburgh Pirates
|
The seasons this player was selected as an All-Star.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| All-Star 1× |
1979
St. Louis Cardinals
|
Weekly and monthly awards, with the team represented at the time.
| Honor | Season / team |
|---|---|
| Player of the Week 3× |
1982 · September · Week 13
St. Louis Cardinals
1979 · June · Week 25
St. Louis Cardinals
1979 · September · Week 17
St. Louis Cardinals
|
| Batter of the Month 2× |
1979 · May
St. Louis Cardinals
1978 · September
Pittsburgh Pirates
|
Division and Championship Series wins are credited when OOTP records a postseason appearance for the player with the winning team. Players who did not appear in a postseason game may not be included.